Which cup will keep a hot drink warm longer, Paper,Plastic, Styrofoam, or Glass?
Grade 5
Presentation
Hypothesis
Based on my research, I think styrofoam will keep the hot drink warm longer because it has lower thermal conductivity so the speed of heat transfer will be slow.
Research
Heat can transfer in 3 different ways -
-
Thermal conductivity
-
Thermal convection
-
Radiation
Thermal conductivity happens when heat moves from a source at a higher temperature (liquid) to a source at a lower temperature (cup) until temperature becomes equal. Thermal conductivity of a material determines how good an insulator it is. Materials that are not good at conducting heat are called insulators. So the best materials for insulation are the ones with the lowest thermal conductivity. While some materials are better than others at conducting heat. Materials that are good at conducting heat are called conductors. To keep the liquid warmer, heat transfer needs to be reduced. To lower the speed of heat transfer, a good thermal insulator is needed. In this experiment we will try to determine which material insulates heat the best.
Key Words
-
Insulator- An insulator is a material that doesn’t easily allow heat to pass through it.
-
Thermal conductivity- Thermal conductivity of a material determines how good an insulator it is. It is the ability of a material to conduct/transfer heat.
-
Temperature- It is the measure of hotness or coldness measured in terms of Fahrenheit or Celsius.
Variables
Controlled (constant) variable
-
Starting temperature
-
Amount of water
-
Time
Manipulated (test) variable
-
Different cup material
Responding Variable
-
Change in temperature in each cup at different time intervals
Procedure
-
Gather all materials
-
Boil water in a pan up to 196 F
-
Line up all the cups and pour 150ml into each cup using a measuring cup
-
Measure the temperature of each cup after every 30 seconds until 300 seconds
-
Repeat experiment 2 more times using the same amount of water (150 ml) and starting with the same water temperature.
Observations
Temperature (Fahrenheit) TRIAL 1 |
||||
Time (sec) |
Styrofoam |
Paper |
Plastic |
Glass |
0 |
196 |
196 |
196 |
196 |
30 |
187 |
187 |
177 |
167 |
60 |
179 |
176 |
168 |
163 |
90 |
173 |
169 |
160 |
150 |
120 |
167 |
163 |
154 |
151 |
150 |
163 |
157 |
150 |
144 |
180 |
158 |
154 |
145 |
139 |
210 |
155 |
149 |
140 |
136 |
240 |
151 |
146 |
136 |
132 |
270 |
148 |
143 |
133 |
132 |
300 |
145 |
140 |
129 |
126 |
Temperature (Fahrenheit) TRIAL 2 |
||||
Time (sec) |
Styrofoam |
Paper |
Plastic |
Glass |
0 |
196 |
196 |
196 |
196 |
30 |
183 |
174 |
170 |
165 |
60 |
177 |
168 |
160 |
160 |
90 |
170 |
162 |
159 |
155 |
120 |
165 |
158 |
154 |
150 |
150 |
161 |
154 |
146 |
140 |
180 |
158 |
150 |
143 |
139 |
210 |
153 |
147 |
138 |
137 |
240 |
150 |
143 |
135 |
129 |
270 |
147 |
140 |
132 |
125 |
300 |
144 |
137 |
130 |
122 |
Temperature (Fahrenheit)TRIAL 3 |
||||
Time (sec) |
Styrofoam |
Paper |
Plastic |
Glass |
0 |
196 |
196 |
196 |
196 |
30 |
181 |
178 |
177 |
165 |
60 |
175 |
172 |
161 |
159 |
90 |
169 |
167 |
153 |
152 |
120 |
164 |
160 |
150 |
146 |
150 |
159 |
157 |
143 |
141 |
180 |
155 |
153 |
139 |
137 |
210 |
152 |
150 |
135 |
133 |
240 |
149 |
147 |
134 |
132 |
270 |
146 |
143 |
131 |
129 |
300 |
142 |
139 |
129 |
125 |
Analysis
Three trials were performed and in each trial temperature readings were taken at 30 seconds intervals up to 300 seconds. Styrofoam always showed the highest temperature amongst all 4 different cups. In the end, average of temperature reading at each interval for every cup was taken.
Conclusion
So as per the three trials, Styrofoam keeps the hot liquid warmer for longer time. Followed by paper and then plastic. Glass doesn’t fare well as compared to other cups and recorded the lowest temperature at the end of each trial. So, Styrofoam is the best cup in keeping hot liquid warmer for longer time.
Application
I was intrigued as to why cafe’s use paper cups and if there are other better alternatives. So I chose the topic ‘Which cup will keep a hot drink warm longer: paper, plastic, styrofoam, or glass?’ In this experiment it was found that Styrofoam keeps the hot liquid warmer for longer time.
So this raised another question, that why aren’t the cafe’s using styrofoam instead. Then I did some further research and found that styrofoam is more harmful to the environment. Also, heat can cause chemicals to release from the foam and into the food. Repeated use of these cups can be a health risk.
So Styrofoam even though keeps hot drink warmer, it's use should be very limited. Example, you can use it in cold months if you are outdoors.
Sources Of Error
INSTRUMENTAL ERROR:
- Thermometer reading
-TImer reading
-Wrong measurement due to miscalibration.
ENVIRONMENTAL ERROR:
- Different room temperature for diff trials
HUMAN ERROR
-Input wrong readings in the table.
-Read wrong data from equipments.
PROCEDURAL ERROR:
-Use of different procedure for different trials.
Acknowledgement
I would like to express my gratitude to my teacher Mrs. Parhar and Khalsa School Calgary for providing me their support , guidance and environment to learn and grow.
I am grateful to my parents for their motivation and encouragement given to me in completing this project.
Finally, I would like to thank CYSF for providing us the platform to show our project work and exchange knowledge.